Can People Change? Why We Stay Stuck in Unpleasant Equilibria
Updated: Nov 5
“People don’t change.”
You have probably said it, or heard it, after watching someone repeat the same behavior for years despite the problems it creates. Their habits are damaging their health, their marriage, their friendships or their finances. Sometimes they can even explain perfectly well what they are doing wrong.
And yet, nothing changes. It is tempting to conclude that people simply are who they are.
We know that our brains remain capable of learning and updating throughout life. The problem is that a system that has found a workable way of functioning has little reason to abandon it.
Our brains are not primarily trying to make us happy. They are trying to keep us functioning in an uncertain world. The most direct way to achieve that is to keep us in an environment they can sufficiently predict and know how to navigate. And that means we can settle into surprisingly unpleasant equilibria.
A relationship can be conflictual and lonely and still last for twenty years. A job can make us miserable and still feel safer than leaving. A behavior can repeatedly create problems and still remain our preferred response.
The situation does not have to be good for us to stay put. It only needs to remain more tolerable than the perceived risk and cost of doing something different.
Seen this way, change becomes quite straightforward. We tend to change when the perceived cost of staying the same becomes greater than the perceived cost of changing.
And there are two ways that equation can shift.
Reality can bring us new information that make our brain's predictions about staying the same more costly.
Or we can build capacities that make changing less costly: better emotional regulation, greater autonomy, better skills, stronger support systems, and a greater ability to tolerate uncertainty, loss or discomfort.
Often, both need to happen.
The Cost of Changing Is a Prediction
When we consider changing, our brain tries to anticipate what that change will cost us.
Some of those costs are concrete: losing money, disrupting a family, giving up status, moving home, or losing a relationship.
Others are emotional: facing rejection, shame, loneliness, conflict, uncertainty, grief, or the discomfort of doing something unfamiliar.
But these costs are not known for sure in advance. They are predictions generated by our brain's internal model of ourselves and the world. And that model is imperfect. It is shaped by our past experiences, beliefs and biases. And those predictions tend to be conservative: what you already know how to navigate is easier to anticipate than what you have never tried.
There is a basic reason for this conservatism: doing what we already know how to do is relatively cheap. Changing is expensive.
Repeated behaviors become increasingly automatic. They require less conscious attention, deliberation and effort. We don't have to reconsider every decision from scratch; our brain can rely on responses that have worked well enough before.
Doing something differently interrupts that efficiency.
We have to notice the habitual response before acting on it, inhibit it, consider alternatives, choose a different behavior and keep doing this repeatedly before the new response becomes more automatic. This requires attention and executive control, making new behavior more cognitively costly than simply repeating an established one. Try brushing your teeth with your other hand and you’ll feel how costly even a small change is for the brain.
On top of that, you pay the cost before you know whether it will pay off.
The old strategy may be painful, but it is familiar, relatively automatic and has kept us functioning so far. The new strategy requires energy and introduces uncertainty.
So the status quo has a structural advantage.
An unpleasant equilibrium can therefore remain preferable to an uncertain alternative—not because we really enjoy it, but because maintaining it may still be cheaper and more predictable than changing it.
When New Information Changes the Equation
If our decisions are based on predictions, then new information matters when it changes those predictions. This is particularly visible in relationships.
Imagine someone who regularly behaves in ways that hurt their partner. They may have heard “I'm unhappy with this” dozens of times. They know there will be arguments, tears, anger or periods of distance. They may genuinely dislike those consequences.
But if the relationship has repeatedly survived them and eventually returned to the same equilibrium, “I'm unhappy with this” may no longer contain much new information.
The effective prediction remains:
This is painful, but this is workable. We fight, we suffer, and we stay together.
Now compare that with:
“I'm starting to question whether I want to stay in this relationship.”
This is not simply a more forceful version of the same complaint. It is new information.
The person's predictions may have included conflict, dissatisfaction and even recurring threats. It may not have included the possibility of really losing the relationship.
Suddenly, the predicted cost of not changing has gone up.
The same principle applies outside relationships. “My doctor keeps telling me I should exercise” may fit comfortably inside an existing model for years. A diagnosis that reveals the concrete consequences of not doing so may not.
This helps explain why repeated feedback can produce almost no change while one piece of genuinely new information produces a sudden shift. The brain updates when reality contradicts something it was counting on to remain true, what neuroscientists call a prediction error. Hearing again what it already expected doesn’t do that.
When They Change Too Late
You have probably heard a version of this story. Maybe you have lived it.
For years, one partner asks for something to be different. More presence. Less drinking. Less criticism. More help with the children. Some sign that the relationship still matters. The other partner listens, sometimes apologizes, sometimes gets defensive, and nothing lasting changes.
Then one day, the first partner leaves. Or announces they have signed a lease.
And suddenly, the person who “couldn’t change” books a therapist. Stops drinking. Comes home early, plans dinners, asks real questions, says the words that were asked for all those years. Within weeks, they become the partner who was being requested for a decade.
From the outside, it can look absurd, even cruel. Where was this person all along? Why now, when it’s too late? The one who left often concludes: If they could do it now, they could have done it then. They just didn’t care enough.
That is one reading. There is another, and it is more useful if you are the one currently waiting for someone to change: the change came when the impactful information finally arrived.
For years, the partner asking for change was sending one message: I’m unhappy. And the relationship absorbed it. The other person’s working assumption (painful, but workable; we fight and we stay) was never contradicted. When the leaving came, it was not a stronger version of the same complaint. It was a new piece of information that broke the old equilibrium.
The tragedy is that by the time this information arrives, it often arrives as a done deal. The person who left had been updating their own picture of the relationship for a long time: doubting, detaching, imagining a life elsewhere. The person who stayed was still working from the old picture. When they finally caught up, there was nothing left to negotiate.
None of this means the person who didn’t change carries no responsibility. They heard the complaints. They chose, again and again, not to take them seriously enough. Their behavior is theirs.
But if you are the one hoping for change right now, there is a question worth asking yourself before it is too late:
Does the other person know what I know about the state of this relationship?
What We Don’t Say
When you have been asking someone to change for a long time, it is common to keep repeating the request while withholding precisely the information that would show them the old equilibrium is no longer viable.
You may not have told your partner that you are seriously considering leaving. That you have looked at apartments, spoken to a lawyer, imagined a life without them, or quietly started making plans.
You may not have told them that your feelings have changed. That you feel increasingly detached, that you no longer look forward to spending time together, or that your attraction has faded.
Sometimes the missing information is even more consequential: an emotional or physical affair, feelings for someone else, or the realization that another relationship is beginning to meet needs that are no longer being met at home.
From your side, these can feel like more intense ways of saying “I’m unhappy.” From your partner’s side, they are new data about the state of the relationship.
Without them, the relationship may look far more stable to them than it actually is. They know there are problems, perhaps serious ones. But they still expect you to stay, because until now, that is what has always happened. Meanwhile, important changes are taking place outside their field of view.
This creates an information asymmetry. You are updating your picture of the relationship with information your partner doesn’t have.
You may already be thinking: I don’t know if I can live like this much longer.
While they are still thinking: We’re going through the same problems we’ve always had, but ultimately we’ll stay together.
As long as the missing information remains hidden, their version can survive. Revealing it changes the equation. The cost of continuing the same behavior is no longer theoretical or distant. The relationship they assumed would always be there may already be moving away from them.
Of course, receiving that information doesn’t guarantee change. They may decide that changing still costs more than losing the relationship. They may deny, minimize or distort what they hear rather than take it in. But without the information, they are making their choices about a relationship that no longer exists.
If you recognize yourself on either side of this asymmetry, as the one who keeps quiet or the one who doesn’t hear, it can help to see which protective patterns are shaping it. The free Protective Patterns Quiz is a good place to start.
We Want Change Without Losing Continuity
If this information is so important, why do we withhold it? Often because revealing it risks destabilizing our own life too.
Saying “I’m unhappy with this” leaves the structure of a relationship largely intact.
Saying “I’ve been thinking seriously about leaving” may not. Disclosing an affair, admitting feelings for someone else, or revealing that you have already taken steps toward separation introduces consequences you can no longer fully control. The other person might become angry, withdraw, leave first, demand a decision, tell other people, change financial arrangements, or simply stop relating to you in the same way.
Until you disclose it, you can sometimes preserve both worlds. You can privately explore alternatives, meet some needs elsewhere, imagine leaving, or emotionally distance yourself while keeping the security and familiarity of the existing relationship.
Withholding preserves continuity. But that continuity also includes the other person not changing.
This is the trade-off that is easy to miss. You want change without disruption. You want your partner to understand how serious things have become, but without risking the relationship before you have a plan B. You want them to behave differently, but without withdrawing the accommodations that make their current behavior sustainable. You want a different equilibrium while preserving most of the conditions that maintain the existing one.
Sometimes that works. Small amounts of new information can be enough to produce gradual change. But sometimes it doesn’t. If the current equilibrium remains workable enough, the cost of changing may simply stay higher than the cost of carrying on. For that to shift, something about the equilibrium itself may have to change.
This doesn’t mean manufacturing consequences, making threats you don’t mean, or deliberately creating instability to force someone to act. It means recognizing that meaningful change and perfect continuity are sometimes incompatible goals. If you want something to change, you may have to tolerate some uncertainty about what things will look like afterward.
Clarity, Not Control
There is a limit to all of this, and it matters: you cannot make someone change.
Not your partner. Not your parent, your sibling, your adult child or your closest friend. You can’t do their updating for them, and you can’t decide for them what they will invest in. Whether they change depends on their own cost equation (their capacities, their fears, their values), and most of that is out of your reach.
What you can do is give them the clearest possible view of reality. Tell them what is actually true about where you stand, what you can and cannot keep living with, and what has already shifted on your side. Then let their choice be theirs.
Clarity, not control.
This is different from an ultimatum. An ultimatum is designed to produce a specific behavior; it is an attempt to steer the outcome. Clarity is information. It says: this is the real state of things, so that whatever you decide, you decide it knowingly. You can still name consequences, such as “If this continues, I won’t stay,” but as a description of your own limits, not as a lever you pull while hoping never to use it.
Clarity also relieves you of a job that was never yours. If you have spent years searching for the right words, the right tone or the right moment that would finally make them change, you have been carrying responsibility for an outcome you never controlled. Once they have accurate information, what they do with it is theirs. And it tells you something too. Someone who sees the full picture and still doesn’t change is giving you new information about your own situation.
When the relationship isn’t safe
Everything above assumes a relationship where honesty is emotionally risky but not dangerous. If you are in an abusive relationship, the equation is different.
Abuse is not only physical. It can take the form of intimidation, threats, coercive control, constant monitoring, financial control, or cutting you off from the people who support you. In these situations, your priority is not to give the other person a fair chance to update. It is your safety, and the safety of any children involved.
Preparing your exit carefully is not deceit, and it is not betrayal. Putting money aside, gathering important documents, finding somewhere to go, confiding in people you trust and contacting a domestic violence organization are ways of protecting yourself.
You don’t owe advance notice to someone who uses information against you. Announcing that you are leaving before you are ready can increase the risk, because the period around a separation is often when abusive behavior escalates. Specialist services can help you plan a departure that keeps you safe.
The principle of seeing reality clearly still holds here, but it applies to you first: recognizing that this is not a relationship where honesty will be met with change, and that protecting yourself is not a failure of honesty.
Capacities Change The Equation
Change introduces uncertainty. One way to make change less frightening is to become more confident that we will be able to cope with whatever happens.
We don't need to know that a difficult conversation will go well. We need to trust that we can handle it if it doesn't.
We don't need to know that leaving a relationship will make us happier. We need enough confidence that if we end up alone, grieving or questioning our decision, we will somehow be okay.
This is what capacities give us.
Emotional regulation helps us trust that difficult feelings won't collapse us.
Emotional autonomy makes the loss of a relationship painful without making it feel unsurvivable. A grounded sense of self-worth makes rejection or shame hurt without turning it into proof that we are worthless. Communication skills make conflict easier to navigate. Financial autonomy gives us practical options. A strong and diverse support system means that losing one important source of support does not leave us with none.
Capacity increases our confidence that we can survive uncertainty.
And this modifies our perception of change. The more we trust our ability to adapt, recover and find new solutions, the less threatening unfamiliar alternatives become. We don't need to preserve the existing equilibrium at all costs because our sense of safety no longer depends entirely on knowing what happens next.
Capacity therefore lowers the perceived cost of changing. It also lowers the perceived cost of honesty.
If telling the truth could jeopardize a relationship I believe I cannot live without, withholding information may feel like the only viable option. If I trust that I will somehow be okay even if the relationship changes or ends, I have much more freedom to say what is actually true.
The same applies to the person receiving the information.
If acknowledging a mistake threatens to collapse my sense of worth, denial may feel safer.
If my self-worth is sufficiently grounded, I can tolerate the realization that I behaved badly, take responsibility and still remain intact.
So greater capacity does not tell you what choice to make. It gives you more choices you can afford to consider.
And that may be one of the most important conditions for change: not becoming certain that the alternative will work, but becoming sufficiently confident that if it doesn't, you will still find a way forward.
When Capacity Feels Out of Reach
If capacities make uncertainty less threatening, emotional wounds can do the opposite.
We often describe an abandonment wound as a fear of being left, a defectiveness wound as a fear that something is wrong with us, or an inadequacy wound as a fear of not being good enough.
But the fear itself may not be the core of the wound.
Most people don't want to be abandoned. Most people find rejection, failure or discovering that they have hurt someone painful.
The deeper difference may lie in what we believe we are capable of if what we fear actually happens.
(This is why in the program we prefer to speak of scarcity belief).
With an abandonment wound, our underlying prediction may be:
I don't believe I can develop enough emotional autonomy to be okay without this person.
With a defectiveness or unworthiness wound:
I don't believe I can hold my sense of self-worth to remain okay if other people see my vulnerable side or reject me.
With an inadequacy wound:
I don't believe I can develop the competence or confidence I would need to meet what life asks of me.
In that sense, an emotional wound is not only a prediction that something painful might happen. It is also a prediction that the capacity we would need to face that outcome is somehow unavailable to us.
That belief changes our cost equation dramatically.
If I believe I could eventually be okay after losing a relationship, abandonment is painful. But if I believe I could never develop the emotional autonomy required to be okay alone, abandonment can feel catastrophic.
If I believe my self-worth can remain intact while acknowledging my flaws, admitting that I behaved badly is painful. But if I believe my worth ultimately depends on being seen as good, accepting the same information can feel much more threatening.
This also helps explain why wounds can become self-reinforcing (and why we call them wounds).
If I believe I cannot cope with abandonment, I will naturally invest energy in preventing abandonment. If I believe I cannot tolerate rejection, I will avoid exposing myself to it. If I believe failure would confirm my inadequacy, I may avoid situations in which failure is possible.
These strategies protect me from having to rely on capacities I don't believe I can possess. But they also deprive me of opportunities to discover that those capacities can be developed.
Change then requires understanding that my prediction may be biased, and experiences that gradually allow a different prediction to become credible:
I didn't know how I would cope, but I did.
This was hard, but I remained intact.
I couldn't control what happened, but I found a way forward.
Over time, the question can shift from “How do I make sure this never happens?” to “If it happens, can I trust myself to eventually find a way through it?”
Values Change the Equation Too
So far, we have looked at change mostly in terms of what feels safe, costly or manageable. But human behavior is not driven by comfort and security alone. Our values also enter the equation.
If honesty matters deeply to me, withholding important information has a cost even if nobody ever discovers the truth. I may experience guilt, internal conflict or a loss of self-respect because my behavior is inconsistent with the person I want to be.
If I value being a caring partner, repeatedly seeing the damage my behavior causes can make continuing that behavior increasingly difficult to tolerate.
If I value autonomy, remaining dependent may eventually become more painful than the uncertainty involved in becoming independent.
Values can therefore raise the internal cost of not changing, even when nothing in the outside world has changed.
This is one reason guilt can be useful, but shame can be destructive.
Guilt tells us that our behavior has moved away from something that matters to us: I don't want to behave this way. I need to repair this or do something differently.
Shame work very differently. Instead of “I did something that conflicts with my values,” the conclusion becomes “What I did proves something bad about who I am". When acknowledging reality threatens our entire sense of worth, it can become less costful to hide, minimize or blame than to face the impact of our actions.
Values also influence which capacities we are willing to spend energy developing.
Building capacity is costly. Becoming more emotionally autonomous, learning to tolerate conflict, developing communication skills, building financial independence or grounding our self-worth takes time, effort and repeated discomfort.
If honesty matters to me but I find honesty terrifying, I have a choice about where to put that effort. I can invest energy in hiding information, avoiding difficult conversations, rationalizing my choices and preserving the conditions that allow me not to tell the truth.
Or I can invest that energy in becoming someone who is increasingly able to tolerate the consequences of honesty.
Valuing honesty does not automatically make me honest. But it gives me a reason to build the capacities that make honesty easier to bear.
This is where explanation and responsibility meet.
Our current capacities constrain the choices that feel available to us. Our wounds may make some of those capacities seem out of reach. But over time, what we repeatedly choose to invest in also matters.
Values help determine which costs we are willing to bear — and which capacities we decide are worth building.
So, Can People Change?
Yes. But being capable of change does not mean that change will happen.
Our current way of functioning has a structural advantage. It is familiar, relatively automatic, and has kept us going so far—even when it has also made us unhappy.
For change to become more likely, the equation has to shift.
Sometimes reality raises the cost of staying the same. New information reveals that the current equilibrium is no longer viable.
Sometimes capacity lowers the cost of changing. We become more confident that even if we cannot predict what will happen, we will somehow be able to cope with it.
Our emotional wounds can bias that equation by making us believe some outcomes will be unbearable and some capacities are permanently out of reach.
And our values influence it too: they can make living out of alignment increasingly costly, while giving us a reason to invest in the capacities we need to behave differently.
None of this guarantees change.
Faced with new information, someone may update their model and change their behavior. They may evaluate that the cost of changing is still greater than the cost of losing what they have. Or they may protect the existing model through denial, blame or avoidance.
You cannot control which one they will choose.
What you can do is make sure their choice is made in contact with reality.
Sometimes that means saying what is actually true, even when doing so threatens the continuity you would prefer to preserve. It means resisting the temptation to absorb every consequence, conceal every shift in your feelings, or maintain an appearance of stability that no longer reflects what is happening.
Because if you keep protecting the old equilibrium, you may never discover whether the other person is willing to leave it. Or they may find out only when it is too late.
And if the relationship isn’t safe, it means seeing that reality clearly for yourself, and protecting yourself first.
Perhaps, then, the useful question is not simply:
Can this person change?
But:
Do they have accurate enough information to understand the cost of not changing?
Do they believe they can develop the capacities required to do something different?
And when reality finally challenges the old equilibrium, what do they choose to invest in?
Sometimes the only way to find out whether someone will change is to stop protecting both of you from the uncomfortable reality.
If you recognised yourself in this post, the patterns quiz can help you identify which protective patterns are most present in your life — and understand what may be keeping them in place.
About The Adventure Within
Most of us were never taught how to handle the complexity of being human — competing needs, uncertain relationships, emotions that don't wait for convenient moments. Without those skills, we develop shortcuts: ways of thinking and behaving that help us cope, but can eventually keep us stuck.
The Adventure Within helps you build the capacities that give you more choice — to regulate your emotions, see reality more clearly, understand what you need, communicate effectively, and stay connected to yourself while connecting deeply with others.
Want to go beyond understanding and start building those capacities?



Comments